When I pick
up books or stories to read I usually look at the title which doesn’t give away
much but still gives me a sense of what the story maybe about. So when I saw
the title ‘topi’ for the first time I thought it would be story about two
friends and the growth of their relationship around this ‘topi’. But writer
Sanjay Sahay represents the Topi in a way that I hadn’t really thought off.
Topi is a
story about a common man named Ramai who struggles to makes ends meet. The loss
of this job only makes his problems worse. His nagging wife, the judgemental
society and the local goon have made him meek, timid and someone with low self –
esteem. His frustration and angry about being a poor commoner come out only
when he drives the DSP’s jeep through town. This ride although momentarily, changes
his life.
The story is
set in a small town of Bihar (probably) given that our author Sanjay Sahay is
from Bihar at a time when poverty, corruption, unemployment etc. were at it its
peak or should I say quite prominent. The writer beautifully brings out the
regular struggles of a common man and the dominance of power both legal and
illegal and how they affect the thought process of not only an individual but
also the society at large.
What I liked
about the story was that along with the representation of power and struggles
of the common man it also brought out the beauty of a small town. When Ramai is
laid off he is given a uniform for the work he did and also maybe because the
union couldn’t do much for him and the others like him. Another aspect was a
small town which was seen was that the news about Ramai unemployment reached
the others even before he reached home. You could say that there is no level privacy
in such towns but at the same time there is a feeling of oneness among the
people maybe because they amount of fear they have for the local goon Baalu and
the DSP are on the same level.
The main
characters of the story are Ramai and the Topi itself. The DSP and Baalu along
with the society help build Ramai character and in a way make him who he is. Both
these characters (DSP and Baalu) represent both legal and illegal power. The Topi
represents this power. For example, when Ramai goes to the DSP along with his
mama the DSP knows that he can’t really do much for poor Ramai but instead of
helping him looks at Ramai as meat or “prey” who is walking into the lion’s den
willingly. In my opinion we can see this level of corruption even today. Even if
one wants to take the right path or the path of honesty he is only hurt more. An
honest individual has no place and as a result this honest person also takes
the route of bribery and corruption in order to get work done. (I say this
after personal experience.)
There is a
flat character in the story named Babban, the local goon before Baalu, who is
part of the assembly or is an MLA. We see this even today. The people at power
are local goon or people with connections to local goons and have criminal
records that are never ending. This is another reason why power is misused more
than it being actually used for the benefit of the common people. So when you
give power in the hands of those who only want to use that power to fill up their
pockets (Babban and Baalu) while the common man (Ramai) struggle to make ends
meet the future of not just our country but any country that functions in this
manner is bound to have high level and deep seated corruption which is very
difficult and close to impossible to eradicate.
The first
time Ramai wears the Topi is to protect himself from the cold and doesn’t really
realise what he had done and the power of the topi until the traffic police
saluted him and pretended to do his job. But even after he realised the power
one Topi he didn’t take it off instead kept it on and wanted to see how else or
what else the Topi could do. At this point every action and thought was no
longer Ramai’s but was of the Topi. It was as if the Topi and its power had
consumed the under confident and meek Ramai and transformed him into a person
full of confidence and so much power that it even made Baalu change his colours
momentarily.
In my
opinion the Topi came as a ray of hope for Ramai as he had begun thinking about
mustering money for the bribe so that he could to wear a topi. All the time he
had the Topi on his head he was respected. More than anything else he was respected
as a human being and I think that’s what we all want. But power is something
that doesn’t allow for this to happen. Why is it that the common man has to
depend on someone with a “Topi” just get what is his right? Isn’t power for the
deserving too? Aren’t hardworking, honest individual entitled to respect and a
respectable life?
Once you
understand what role the Topi plays in the story you tend to overlook certain
things that the writer has added just to bring out the theme of the story. During
our discussions we questioned if Baalu hadn’t recognised that it was Ramai who
was wearing the DSP’s Topi? And when he did why didn’t he do anything about it?
Also, given that Ramai was a meek and timid person how come he didn’t take off
the Topi when he realised what he had done? Why did he keep it on? Where did he
get this sudden confidence from? It looked like as if some parts of the climax
were forced just to convey the message behind the story.
His form of
discussion of text really helps as it brings various views to the table. It help
me reason out my own views regarding the story and also added perspective to
it. Initially I didn’t look at the Topi as a character but merely an object
around which the story was centred but it was through these discussions that I was
able to understand the text better.
This experience
was great fun and I think we should do this more often!!
you have covered almost all the aspects that we dicussed when we had our literary circle group discussion. I could relatw with your blog as it has helped me to look at few other things :-)
ReplyDelete